Occupied Japan 1945 - 1952: Gender, Class, Race

Yamakawa Kikue

1890-1980, born: Japan
Socialist, Writer, Government Official

Although Yamakawa Kikue was able to trace her family heritage back to the lower ranking samurai class, her own life and writings were thoroughly radical. Her mother was born in the former Mito domain, a branch of the ruling Tokugawa family which generated one of the most famous slogans of the mid 19th century: sōnno jōi (revere the emperor and repel the barbarian). After the Meiji Restoration, when other slogans dominated the scene, such as kaikoku (open country) and bunmei kaika (civilization and enlightenment), that status was permanently lost when the entire samurai class was done away with in the 1870s. In 1877, lower level samurai received small payoffs and were forced to find employment. Many years later, Yamakawa in a loving tribute to her mother and family would publish a richly detailed work of the lives and experiences of ordinary samurai as survival on low fixed incomes became increasingly difficult in the rapidly changing economy and society of the 19th century. The work, published in 1943 and re-issued years later, has been translated as Women of the Mito Domain.
As a young woman, however, Yamakawa gave little heed to her conservative background. She was a graduate of the Tsuda English Academy in 1912. At age 17, Yamakawa (born Aoyama) married Kawakami Hajime (1880-1958), future professor of economics at Kyoto University, labor leader, and communist agitator who, along with his wife, was often in trouble with the law and the police. While other activist women of the 1920s, including the feminists were working for gender equality and asking for the vote, Yamakawa followed the socialist path. On May Day, 1921, she helped to found the Red Wave Society (Seiirankai), a group of Japanese socialist women. It was still one year before the Japanese Parliament would do away with the Police Bill preventing Japanese women from engaging in political activities. Nevertheless, women were consigned to women’s sections of parties, including the socialists, or to women’s divisions of trade unions. Throughout the 1920s and 1930s, Yamakawa was constant in intellectual growth as a socialist-feminist. She joined the motherhood protection debate but gave much thought to ways in which women could be seen by themselves and others as independent in life, thought, and work and not imagined solely as good wives/wise mothers or dutiful daughters. Expanding women’s identity from object to subject was as was as much a question on the left of the political spectrum as among conservatives. But after the widening of Japan’s war against China in 1937 and the West, in common with other women activists, she had less to say about the evils of war and war mobilization and more about the workplace as a site of opportunities for women. Also, her husband was jailed for dangerous thoughts in 1937. As historian Beth Katzoff has suggested:
Yamakawa argued that women, as women and as mothers, could contribute to the nation, and consequently, to the war. Although she never wrote that war was good for women, Yamakawa did not promote progressive resistance due to such wartime constraints as censorship and threat of incarceration. Still, she remained a feminist; Yamakawa’s use of the language of nationalism to promote her feminism demonstrates that feminism can be pragmatic as well as complicit with structures of power.(1)
In a harsher verdict, Yamakawa, together with other feminists in the period after 1937, was, though a leftist, more prone to interact with the increasingly authoritarian wartime state than to oppose or challenge it. Cooperation was seen as a way to make limited public gains for women. How, then, would she interact with the state as refashioned in Occupied Japan but still run by men?
In September 1947, when the new Labor Ministry was created to carry out fundamental reforms under new labor legislation, it included a Women’s and Children’s Bureau. Basic among the new laws, was the Labor Standards Act of April 1947. Following considerable debate among Japanese women activists over the choice of the historic first bureau head, Yamakawa Kikue, age 57, emerged as the consensus candidate. She was also acceptable to Americans in MacArthurs’s General Headquarters, in particular Lt. Ethel Weed, head of the Women’s Bureau in the Civil Information and Education Section. Yamakawa served three years, ably assisted by prewar labor inspector Tanino Setsu, who later took over the bureau, 1955-65. During Yamakawa's time, considerable attention was given to equal wages for women, a cause too soon not only for Japan but elsewhere in the industrialized world. Another issue carried over from the prewar and wartime years was protection of women workers and curtailment of child labor. It was apparent in some cases that women were capable or work denied to them by virtue of their sex. Yamakawa was also responsible for launching Women's Week, beginning April 1949.
Even for Yamakawa, the ideal of good wife/wise mother prevailed in the media. An interview with Yamakawa in the Tokyo Times, November 12, 1948, indicated that in the mind of the journalist, her “greatness and superiority lies in the fact that she performed her duties as a housewife and mother in parallel to her work as a pioneer.” She was described as “a lady less than five feet [dressed] in black, not very attractive and with a dark complexion without a trace of face power.” She was grandmotherly but also “not just any ordinary old woman.” When asked about the goals of the Women’s and Children’s Bureau, she said:
It is the duty of the Women and Children’s Bureau to protect and enlighten the women and minors and to do work that will benefit them. For that, we must know above all the actual situation of the women and minors. It is necessary, first of all, to make investigations into the actual situation of the daily life of the people in order to find out what is the most urgent problem of working women or war widows. (2)
As to the kind of work she intended to do in the future, Yamakawa answered:
In backward countries, the big work of the women is to find out the sort of laws which should be enacted. But in Japan, the laws have changed quite suddenly, and the people have been given equal rights. The present situation is that the people do not know the true value of this. We want all of the women to have common sense enough to go to the domestic relations court when a divorce case comes. It is desirable that laws disadvantageous to women be revised.(2)
Throughout her long adult years, Yamakawa was a prolific writer of essays and books. Her life, thought, and professional career are important in showing not only the contributions of women to the evolving Japanese socialist movement, but also in implementing reforms of significance to working women and minors in a still impoverished early postwar economy.

*************
(1)Abstract, "Feminism at War: Yamakawa Kikue (1931-1945)," paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Asian Studies, 1997.
(2) Adapted from translation of interview, records of Women’s Bureau, Civil Information and Education Section, Record Group 331 (SCAP, Japan), National Archives and Records Administration, College Park.

References

Hane, Mikiso (Ed. and Transl.). "The Sekirankai." Reflections on the Way to the Gallows: Rebel Women in Prewar Japan. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1988; 161-174.
Hopper, Helen M. Chapter 11, "Populist Politics (1946-1947)." A New Woman of Japan: A Political Biography of Kato Shidzue. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1997; 196-215.
Hunter, Janet. "Gendering the Labor Market: Evidence from the Interwar Textile Industry." Gendering Modern Japanese History. Eds. Barbara Molony and Kathleen Uno. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Asia Center and distributed by Harvard University Press, 2005; 359-392.
Mackie, Vera. Creating Socialist Women in Japan: Gender, Labor and Activism, 1900-1937. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997.
Mackie, Vera. Feminism in Modern Japan: Citizenship, Embodiment, and Sexuality. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2003.
Macnaughtan, Helen. Women, Work and the Japanese Economic Miracle: The Case of the Cotton Textile Industry, 1945-1975. New York: RoutledgeCurzon, 2005.
Pharr, Susan J. "Bureaucratic Politics and Social Reform: the Women's and Minors' Bureau in Occupied Japan." The Occupation of Japan: Educational and Social Reform. Ed. Thomas W Burkman. Norfolk, VA: The MacArthur Memorial, 1982; 401-423.
Toyoda, Maho. "Roots of Women's Labor Policy in Japan: Establishing the Women's and Minors' Bureau in the U.S. Occupation." Workshop B: Women and Social Change. Accessed 2006 December 21 on the World Wide Web at http://www.bris.ac.uk/ceas/events/conferences/gdp/abstracts
/b/papers/maho_toyoda_paper.doc.
Tsurumi, E. Patricia. “Visions of Women and the New Society in Conflict: Yamakawa Kikue versus Takamure Itsue.” Japan's Competing Modernities: Issues in Culture and Democracy, 1900-1930. Ed. Sharon Minichiello, Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1998; 335-357.
Tsurumi, E. Patricia. "The Accidental Historian, Yamakawa Kikue." Gender & History 2 (1994): 258-276.
Wilson, Sandra. Review of Vera Mackie, “Creating Socialist Women in Japan.” Asian Studies Review 22/3 (September 1998).
Yamakawa, Kikue. Women of the Mito Domain: Recollections of Samurai Family Life. Trans. Kate Wildman Nakai. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press, 1992. Reissued by Stanford University Press, 1998.