Episode 1: Dunkirk or Devil-May-Care

[00:06 - 00:19]
The shadow of the lion.
[00:19 - 00:24]
Emerging from a memorable immovable palace. Britain today faces
[00:24 - 00:28]
the formidable task of defining the future.
[00:28 - 00:32]
And this is our story a story of truth for no longer
[00:32 - 00:37]
stands can tell a lie and a deceptive his shadow is but an
[00:37 - 00:40]
apparition. You did yesterday his profile.
[00:40 - 00:57]
Mrs..
[00:57 - 01:02]
Temple transmission. Heard in London's comedy street in
[01:02 - 01:07]
Coventry in Oxford and. Rhythm
[01:07 - 01:28]
of a new revolution in Britain.
[01:28 - 01:42]
Programme one Dunkirk or devil may care.
[01:42 - 01:47]
From an Indiana University Radio documented essay about contemporary
[01:47 - 01:52]
Britain. We present the shadow of the lion with William Kinzer
[01:52 - 01:54]
as your net writer.
[01:54 - 02:04]
Most Americans feel quite close to Britain. Many of our beginnings
[02:04 - 02:09]
begin there and the scars of those bitter rebellious
[02:09 - 02:13]
beginnings have since been healed by history leaving only a page or so to
[02:13 - 02:19]
chronicle the time and the lasting trust of common ties.
[02:19 - 02:21]
We speak the same language for instance.
[02:21 - 02:29]
I haven't noticed how genes get in next door. I love she said.
[02:29 - 02:33]
And I dads are always mouthing about spending as Braff down the
[02:33 - 02:38]
problem. But then I want to be done about it. Now I have brought up about young Jimmy
[02:38 - 02:41]
because I'm doing very well.
[02:41 - 02:45]
Oh OK well we thought we
[02:45 - 02:50]
spoke the same language although we are often reminded of Oscar Wilde who said
[02:50 - 02:55]
in these words we empathy Americans have much in common but there is
[02:55 - 03:00]
always the language barrier. Yet we do find ourselves
[03:00 - 03:05]
together on most things thinking the same thoughts harboring the same
[03:05 - 03:10]
concerns were their lives. But time has made us
[03:10 - 03:15]
individuals too and we're often surprised at how little we
[03:15 - 03:16]
know about each other.
[03:16 - 03:30]
The American tourist he jets in from Albuquerque Sioux City or Brooklyn
[03:30 - 03:35]
he steps from the plane in stereo type camera. Credit cards.
[03:35 - 03:39]
Yankee confidence. He shudders in the damp drizzle that is stereotyped
[03:39 - 03:44]
dumdum shuttering also at the prospect of seeing Europe him two
[03:44 - 03:49]
weeks. But he's game. He stays at the Regent Palace
[03:49 - 03:54]
perhaps wanders about Piccadilly Circus walks up Oxford Street sees
[03:54 - 03:59]
the conventional sights Big Ben St. Paul's Buckingham Palace
[03:59 - 04:04]
in three in lot of days he will have mastered a planked you know a real English
[04:04 - 04:09]
pub written with a double decker bus. Bought a few souvenirs
[04:09 - 04:14]
seemed the changing of the guard and fed the pigeons in Trafalgar Square.
[04:14 - 04:19]
He would depart with distinct opinions of what the English are like what the
[04:19 - 04:24]
future of Britain will be and he will carefully catalogue his
[04:24 - 04:29]
impressions with color slides for the weekly Rotary Club meeting back
[04:29 - 04:30]
home.
[04:30 - 04:32]
But mark you.
[04:32 - 04:37]
Britain is more than can be seen from London's tallest spire the new
[04:37 - 04:41]
GPO tower.
[04:41 - 04:46]
The past room beauty of Britain using proceed all the way
[04:46 - 04:49]
from the wild spree of the Cornish coast.
[04:49 - 04:53]
True the Highland Park of Brigadoon country.
[04:53 - 04:58]
The forever green fields cross hatched by here drillers defied the
[04:58 - 05:03]
simple statistic that more than 52 million people
[05:03 - 05:07]
inhabit some ninety three thousand square miles of land.
[05:07 - 05:12]
Now we're tired out and we've gotten a lot of green space left it sometimes looks as if the whole country
[05:12 - 05:17]
is a garden if you see it from the air. By comparison with the United States or
[05:17 - 05:22]
Australia but there is an awful lot of country left. You can
[05:22 - 05:26]
find villages within 30 miles of London that are still
[05:26 - 05:30]
very little changed from 200 years ago.
[05:30 - 05:35]
Norman Mackenzie is sociologist University of Sussex but now
[05:35 - 05:40]
look beyond the steepled horizon of the country village across the urban
[05:40 - 05:45]
skyline into the hearts and minds of the people.
[05:45 - 05:50]
See for yourself. See the evolution of change. Norman
[05:50 - 05:52]
McKenzie tells it all.
[05:52 - 05:57]
I think the old image of the stuffed shirt Englishman Bob
[05:57 - 06:02]
Hope's famous example of the reading vision or looking up at his rallies making
[06:02 - 06:06]
love to a girl and saying pucker my lips mother and see this picture of
[06:06 - 06:11]
you know the hour of period type and there was something in it of an upper class.
[06:11 - 06:17]
Picture. I think that what's been happening in England in the post-war
[06:17 - 06:22]
years I'm ready to think first of all there's been a big change in the
[06:22 - 06:27]
position of the working class in England. What I might loosely call working class
[06:27 - 06:32]
patterns of life have changed very considerably with increases in
[06:32 - 06:37]
prosperity in better housing better welfare provision more enjoying
[06:37 - 06:42]
employment things of this kind. And you've got a rise of
[06:42 - 06:47]
a whole new section of the population into types of activity which were never available to
[06:47 - 06:52]
them before including education. I think this is one big change I think the other one is the
[06:52 - 06:57]
change among young people. I'm a person who grew up in
[06:57 - 07:02]
the period between the two wars and I think that if I look at young
[07:02 - 07:07]
people today they are very different particularly if one looks at students who
[07:07 - 07:12]
have a great deal to do with their much lived there. I think that much righter in their
[07:12 - 07:17]
interests. I think a much less hidebound much less conservative. Indeed the
[07:17 - 07:21]
criticism of many people today would be not that the English are stuffed shirt
[07:21 - 07:26]
people but there are blue jeans and bearded people and that young people are increasingly setting
[07:26 - 07:28]
the tone.
[07:28 - 07:35]
It's true aristocratic English has been overwhelmed by the
[07:35 - 07:40]
eccentricity index. On top of the modern age it's the thing it's
[07:40 - 07:44]
everywhere. The opulence of them pop the minister Amir still beat the
[07:44 - 07:47]
way out influence on Carnaby Street.
[07:47 - 07:56]
It's everywhere.
[07:56 - 08:01]
But yet there is truth also in the contention that the British are
[08:01 - 08:06]
reserved. You can see that too. It's a treat deeply ingrained in
[08:06 - 08:10]
their existence. Living closely as they do the English are born to
[08:10 - 08:15]
respect the rights and the privacy of others. For instance you can
[08:15 - 08:20]
travel the length of England in a train say from Manchester to London and
[08:20 - 08:25]
sit among six strangers in a compartment and likely as not no effort will
[08:25 - 08:30]
be made to strike an acquaintance. The end tire trip of three to four hours
[08:30 - 08:35]
may be made in absolute silence and the English character I think
[08:35 - 08:40]
is that of not not wanting to present a picture of brashness.
[08:40 - 08:47]
Of loud mouth they have been so odd and I think that. The enjoyment certainly is
[08:47 - 08:51]
reserved and as the Germans probably say little whore I have little high
[08:51 - 08:56]
meaning that one holds one head how I think I was once proud of being a British or
[08:56 - 09:01]
as a secretary to the Bradford Council of Social Services. Urban Scot is
[09:01 - 09:06]
a good judge of character in the English comics I think it is a product
[09:06 - 09:12]
of his education of his early childhood he's always taught that he must
[09:12 - 09:15]
behave himself as an Englishman ought to have.
[09:15 - 09:19]
I'm the cricket field or in the classroom English character is being
[09:19 - 09:23]
molded and to what end.
[09:23 - 09:27]
They're very conceited people in this especially the English middle and
[09:27 - 09:32]
upper classes. The training that they get in what a core public school right is you
[09:32 - 09:37]
know private schools not your not in your sense about private schools.
[09:37 - 09:42]
The training that they get in these schools is calculated to make them feel that
[09:42 - 09:47]
they are a sort of elite that that the lords of creation
[09:47 - 09:52]
Malcolm Muggeridge who enjoys ripping the rug from beneath British
[09:52 - 09:57]
complacency and does it certainly in conceit. This was
[09:57 - 09:59]
extremely useful when we had an empire.
[09:59 - 10:04]
Because if you are ruling a country you were very few and that many
[10:04 - 10:09]
when when we ruled India the 400 million Indians and were never more than ten
[10:09 - 10:13]
thousand. In these people that they kept
[10:13 - 10:19]
it was necessary that they should have the temperament.
[10:19 - 10:22]
But now of course it becomes increasingly absurd.
[10:22 - 10:26]
The former editor of punch and present day author television
[10:26 - 10:31]
personality sits in his book lined study and expresses an opinion
[10:31 - 10:36]
about the constitution of his country when the English are very
[10:36 - 10:41]
proud. Malcolm Muggeridge will tell you. But their pride doesn't always stand
[10:41 - 10:45]
the test of changed circumstances. And in this
[10:45 - 10:50]
precarious age of commerce and economic survival many changes
[10:50 - 10:55]
must occur. What to them is the British attitude
[10:55 - 10:56]
toward change.
[10:56 - 11:02]
They have been in the past the deep conservative people have said they don't like changing in the
[11:02 - 11:06]
things they drive on the left hand side of the road. This is the most
[11:06 - 11:10]
ridiculous thing to do. It leads to even cost lives
[11:10 - 11:15]
because this now is more and more English people take their motor cars the
[11:15 - 11:20]
continent where everybody drives on the right hand side of the road.
[11:20 - 11:25]
It even this absurd mania for going on driving on the left actually costs
[11:25 - 11:30]
lives. Their refusal until now to adopt the metric system
[11:30 - 11:35]
I should say that the absurd tables and things that we have to learn as children
[11:35 - 11:40]
through our mandate and measures and things like that probably add without exaggeration some
[11:40 - 11:45]
six months. Through the process of being
[11:45 - 11:50]
educated they cling to these things. The kind of idiot tenacity
[11:50 - 11:55]
which you go with in a way part of their conceit the feeling that if we do it that way that must be the best
[11:55 - 11:58]
way to do it.
[11:58 - 12:03]
But as Britain struggles to regain her poise in the vortex of
[12:03 - 12:07]
economic emergency her leaders cry out for things to be done
[12:07 - 12:12]
better than ever. In a world of intense competition
[12:12 - 12:17]
efficiency is an essential key to survival. Yet it's
[12:17 - 12:22]
difficult to awaken the people to the realities of the day since they
[12:22 - 12:26]
exist in a peculiar paradox of dire circumstances on one hand
[12:26 - 12:31]
and on equal affluence on the other. What are the
[12:31 - 12:36]
realities you ask Paul Burrell. He's editor of the statist one
[12:36 - 12:41]
of Britain's leading business and economics periodicals.
[12:41 - 12:46]
My experience of course goes back to well before the wrong.
[12:46 - 12:51]
Guy who played the great comfort of a cat in the economic climate
[12:51 - 12:57]
and economic attitude in this country.
[12:57 - 13:01]
But there should be full employment. This is something which
[13:01 - 13:06]
emerged out of a crisis of the 1920s and 1930s.
[13:06 - 13:11]
It's history how the industrial dilemmas of Britain converged in the
[13:11 - 13:16]
general strike of 1926. The incident began
[13:16 - 13:22]
with the coal miners strike soon followed in sympathy by other unions.
[13:22 - 13:27]
The event in consequential in its immediate outcome left many
[13:27 - 13:32]
bitter memories and an indelible creed for the English working man.
[13:32 - 13:36]
Never again he vowed never again would the labor suffer
[13:36 - 13:42]
or sink so low when the good day issues of human dignity. And
[13:42 - 13:46]
so we emerged in England the hard core philosophy and formidable
[13:46 - 13:49]
strength of organized labor.
[13:49 - 13:53]
The British record to me. You've got trade union
[13:53 - 13:57]
jump onto the brain and he can't get away from it.
[13:57 - 14:02]
The power of the trade union treads easily invisibly through
[14:02 - 14:07]
the corridors of government through committees board or come to meetings
[14:07 - 14:12]
only occasionally now does it erupt into violence or vented dispute
[14:12 - 14:18]
but stoppages still reminded them nation of the elevated
[14:18 - 14:22]
status of the British worker. No the worker enjoys of
[14:22 - 14:28]
fools paradise of full employment and an equal compensation.
[14:28 - 14:33]
This every Briton knows the working man now in a year is giving an
[14:33 - 14:38]
engine out of Rocky Mountain each second of the eight being a big person to be
[14:38 - 14:42]
a definite action really to go out. Again a distinction between a working man and a upper
[14:42 - 14:47]
class but now. The working man found him
[14:47 - 14:53]
working conditions and living conditions no wages and far.
[14:53 - 14:57]
From it. Back in action no matter what I continue to go that they're getting a look into the upperclassman.
[14:57 - 15:04]
I don't think I missed that command ever being better off in this
[15:04 - 15:05]
life.
[15:05 - 15:10]
Ordinary lucky man but unfortunately todays worker is
[15:10 - 15:13]
living beyond his nation's means.
[15:13 - 15:18]
Economist Paul Barrow explains the more supply and demand can
[15:18 - 15:23]
be made overnight and the wages and
[15:23 - 15:27]
costs have gone up and that we have downfall that is one of the things we have
[15:27 - 15:31]
Balfour handed great very difficult battlement
[15:31 - 15:36]
international payments. We have tended to import too much. We have
[15:36 - 15:41]
unbalanced tended to export too little and we have been in the balance of payment
[15:41 - 15:43]
difficulties.
[15:43 - 15:47]
Ironically it's a Labor government caught in conflict between the boy and hopes of the
[15:47 - 15:52]
laboring class and the economic undertow of the country. Prime minister
[15:52 - 15:57]
Harold Wilson has never been free to advance the idiology of his party
[15:57 - 16:02]
treading a thin line of support and the perilous path of a month stable
[16:02 - 16:06]
pound Britain's leader has gamely tried to exhort countryman and ally
[16:06 - 16:11]
alike to rally to the cause. Inevitably the British worker became
[16:11 - 16:16]
a focal point of concern. After all wages had risen two and a half
[16:16 - 16:21]
times faster than productivity. Something had to be done to curb a
[16:21 - 16:26]
trend that had priced many British goods out of the world market and brought
[16:26 - 16:30]
inflation at home and it threatened the value of the pound sterling.
[16:30 - 16:35]
Almost everything would be tried a freeze on wages prices and dividends
[16:35 - 16:40]
or restricted military commitment an increase in taxes but to
[16:40 - 16:45]
no avail at 9:33 a cold foggy Saturday
[16:45 - 16:50]
evening of November 967. The word was to be released
[16:50 - 16:55]
the moment many feared came by way of a brief bulletin that interrupted the
[16:55 - 17:00]
Doris Day movies. BBC Britain had at last been forced
[17:00 - 17:01]
to devalue the palm.
[17:01 - 17:12]
Reaction was mixed. The people yes. The world was shocked
[17:12 - 17:17]
but somehow life seemed to go on with the same doubt. Decision
[17:17 - 17:22]
in differences before and while the press and the politicians presided over
[17:22 - 17:26]
Britain's fate the people remained hopeful and didn't shake him
[17:26 - 17:31]
against a veneer of gay irresponsible vitality. The British
[17:31 - 17:37]
scene is a mixed euro mild concern and confused inertia.
[17:37 - 17:41]
But this isn't the first time the British have been on the edge of
[17:41 - 17:45]
uncertainty that people can only be
[17:45 - 17:51]
executives when they when a
[17:51 - 17:53]
crisis arise.
[17:53 - 17:57]
Malcolm Muggeridge would remind you that only until the Nazis were at the Channel
[17:57 - 18:02]
ports did the English fully acknowledge the seriousness of their position
[18:02 - 18:04]
in World War Two.
[18:04 - 18:09]
Then to their credit they were able to deal with the situation without
[18:09 - 18:11]
panicking or losing heart.
[18:11 - 18:17]
Though the proud moments the gilded glowing
[18:17 - 18:22]
hours of endless courage the genesis of heroes and the commonplace
[18:22 - 18:26]
acts of inspiration that welded a nation into one
[18:26 - 18:32]
Dunkirk remembered defeat turned into victory by
[18:32 - 18:36]
dawn as Tweed suited or cloth capped amateurs drawing to the
[18:36 - 18:40]
professionals at the beach. It was everyone's war
[18:40 - 18:46]
and tiny Turnell spent in dark and damp shelters and the
[18:46 - 18:50]
mornings of rubble and smoke and death
[18:50 - 18:56]
and still the indomitable will hail and one for the
[18:56 - 18:59]
British the admiration and respect of all
[18:59 - 19:05]
including the enemy for try as he might he couldn't
[19:05 - 19:07]
conquer the invincible spirit.
[19:07 - 19:40]
When the bubbly personality of people around us
[19:40 - 19:44]
didn't know what to do for a few days they soon got a cross
[19:44 - 19:52]
coming on shore
[19:52 - 19:57]
and the case didn't.
[19:57 - 20:02]
Last week.
[20:02 - 20:04]
And the council started dancing in the pool.
[20:04 - 20:20]
My particular corner of the fire that it
[20:20 - 20:36]
became a beacon
[20:36 - 20:59]
on the pavement and.
[20:59 - 21:01]
I mean and
[21:01 - 21:14]
he and the young
[21:14 - 21:17]
man came my mom
[21:17 - 21:20]
and I.
[21:20 - 21:48]
You are releasing a very.
[21:48 - 21:48]
Very
[21:48 - 21:57]
rash. Do you know why and I just think
[21:57 - 22:04]
it was a chair and I
[22:04 - 22:11]
didn't shout standing in the dead wearing white
[22:11 - 22:14]
and writing class.
[22:14 - 22:29]
From the archives of the BBC voices
[22:29 - 22:35]
reliving the hallmark of human courage the spirit of
[22:35 - 22:40]
Britain and of there are many who can not stand
[22:40 - 22:45]
you or indeed hearken back to better days of dignity and purpose.
[22:45 - 22:50]
And they would wish for an encore the United struggle the all out
[22:50 - 22:53]
effort the Dunkirk spirit. But
[22:53 - 22:57]
somehow sadly it's missing.
[22:57 - 22:59]
I put that out there of your with
[22:59 - 23:06]
deep regret. I am despondent at
[23:06 - 23:12]
the position we find ourselves in in Great Britain the present time. And I
[23:12 - 23:17]
think a very large number of my countrymen share this feel. JM Slater
[23:17 - 23:22]
sales executive expresses an Englishman's feel I'm one of the
[23:22 - 23:26]
many who fully appreciate that our role in the world is one of diminishing
[23:26 - 23:31]
influence. Inevitably the days of our empire have come to an
[23:31 - 23:36]
end and I think nine out of 10 Englishman accept that that
[23:36 - 23:41]
that man coin has one daughter or of course as you and I
[23:41 - 23:47]
well of as far as I can see now descended upon the United States.
[23:47 - 23:52]
What I deprecate about the country is that at the end of the
[23:52 - 23:57]
war when we had such a golden moment when our name stood so
[23:57 - 24:01]
high throughout the world had we worked harder and
[24:01 - 24:06]
industrial and justice for a few years after that
[24:06 - 24:12]
we would have been today in an unassailable position. Unhappily
[24:12 - 24:17]
we tended for many reasons. To sit
[24:17 - 24:22]
back and we gradually seem to take on a philosopher
[24:22 - 24:27]
that the world owed as a living. And unfortunately as far as I can see
[24:27 - 24:32]
in this country that Outlook still prevails today although I think
[24:32 - 24:37]
that with this present crisis that people emerging from this
[24:37 - 24:42]
war sleep and now well Malcolm Muggeridge well
[24:42 - 24:43]
join.
[24:43 - 24:46]
We need irresponsibility.
[24:46 - 24:56]
But look. The shadow of the lion is the silhouette of change.
[24:56 - 25:00]
And whether subtle or obvious. It's everywhere. In
[25:00 - 25:04]
education. The church in the hole. In the
[25:04 - 25:09]
architecture and the arts in miles and motorway and teeming
[25:09 - 25:15]
traffic. In planning and production. In the people.
[25:15 - 25:19]
Yes. Britain can never again be the Britain of a cherished
[25:19 - 25:25]
bygone era. Class lines are clumped. The youths are emerging.
[25:25 - 25:30]
From aristocratic and the management have risen to the fore. Triumph by
[25:30 - 25:33]
technology is the creed of the coming age.
[25:33 - 25:44]
Even Buckingham Palace has called in efficiency experts. Britain
[25:44 - 25:49]
is on the brink of transition and it isn't easy
[25:49 - 25:55]
for change comes hard in a land so deeply endowed with tradition.
[25:55 - 25:59]
On the one hand Britons are alarmed at the insidious encroachments of
[25:59 - 26:04]
modern evils. On the other they are eager to embrace that
[26:04 - 26:09]
comfort and convenience of a bright new world of consumer products.
[26:09 - 26:14]
And so they exist in a skewed toward environment desiring the
[26:14 - 26:19]
best of both worlds. Change though is
[26:19 - 26:24]
inevitable. It's essential if we want things to stay
[26:24 - 26:28]
as they are. Someone once wrote things will have to
[26:28 - 26:33]
change. Recasting old ways can be a tedious and
[26:33 - 26:38]
ticklish task nevertheless. No one knows better than Lord Beeching.
[26:38 - 26:43]
He's the revolutionary who reshaped the British railways into an almost paying
[26:43 - 26:48]
proposition by ruthlessly stripping them of their redundancy.
[26:48 - 26:53]
Now that with ICICI the Imperial chemical industries one of
[26:53 - 26:58]
Britain's largest corporations as Deputy Chairman of the board Lord
[26:58 - 27:02]
Beeching pauses to ponder Britain's rising standard of living.
[27:02 - 27:07]
We have achieved this growth in so doing to a large extent
[27:07 - 27:13]
by continuing to behave as we've always behaved and to
[27:13 - 27:18]
achieve a much higher rate of growth instead of living which we want. I think
[27:18 - 27:21]
we've got to start to behave quite differently.
[27:21 - 27:26]
It's difficult to behave differently weaned on the benefits of a
[27:26 - 27:30]
welfare state nourished in the affluence of material
[27:30 - 27:35]
prosperity. Britain see little need to change except
[27:35 - 27:41]
through as they see the world around them changing. But suddenly the
[27:41 - 27:45]
austere complacency of the establishment has been shaken by the shock
[27:45 - 27:50]
troops of pop culture by the paragons of advertising
[27:50 - 27:55]
of commercialism by the pressures from Europe and America and by the
[27:55 - 28:01]
influx of immigrants and the influence of changing values.
[28:01 - 28:05]
Britain today is taking inventory and
[28:05 - 28:10]
this is our story a story of agonizing self-analysis
[28:10 - 28:14]
and a constant search for a new resolve.
[28:14 - 28:19]
Let the country go back a few years to over Wall
[28:19 - 28:24]
get that kind of grit and get our teeth into this thing and work our
[28:24 - 28:24]
passage.
[28:24 - 28:42]
From Indiana University Radio we have presented dumb Turk or devil may
[28:42 - 28:46]
care program one in a special series of documented essays
[28:46 - 28:51]
about contemporary Britain entitled The shadow of the lion
[28:51 - 28:56]
as written and produced by Lou Roy Gutman. The narrator was William
[28:56 - 29:01]
Kinzer production assistant was John Hopkins the engineer Phil
[29:01 - 29:05]
Murphy program consultant Jeremy ward one time
[29:05 - 29:10]
excerpts were used by special permission from the British Broadcasting Corporation
[29:10 - 29:16]
John Dimmock speaking.
[29:16 - 29:20]
Shadow of the lion has been a series made possible by an Indiana University
[29:20 - 29:22]
faculty research grant.
[29:22 - 29:34]
And there's a presentation of Indiana University Radio.
[29:34 - 29:37]
This is the national educational radio network.