- Series
- The smoking dilemma
- Air Date
- 1968-11-08
- Duration
- 00:14:28
- Episode Description
- A conversation with Dr. Irving Baran, a psychiatrist who helps individuals go through the process of quitting smoking at a San Diego County cessation clinic.
- Series Description
- A series about the complexities of the smoking problem, hosted by Dr. Ralph Grawunder, San Diego State University.
- Subject(s)
- Creator(s)
- KEBS (Producer)San Diego State University (Producer)
- Contributors
- Grawunder, Ralph, 1929- (Host)
- Genre(s)
- Geographic Region(s)
- regions
- Time Period
- 1961-1970
[00:05 - 00:10]
There are at least 20 million ex cigarette smokers in the United States today.
[00:10 - 00:15]
Persons who have successfully given up a very dangerous habit.
[00:15 - 00:20]
Still 70 million Americans continue to smoke despite the fact that most of them
[00:20 - 00:25]
say they would like to stop. I'm Dr. Ralph grinder professor of health education at
[00:25 - 00:30]
San Diego State College. And this is one of a series of programs on the smoking dilemma.
[00:30 - 00:35]
In the next few minutes we'll explore the problems the failures the successes of stopping
[00:35 - 00:40]
smoking. Our guest today is Dr. Irving Baron Saniel
[00:40 - 00:46]
psychiatrist who is working with groups of people who are trying to give up smoking.
[00:46 - 00:49]
Dr. Barron How tough is it really to give up smoking.
[00:49 - 00:55]
I think this fairy said I with a smoker there are smokers and there are smokers there
[00:55 - 00:59]
are all kinds of different personalities
[00:59 - 01:06]
who are smokers there isn't one personality type who makes up a smoker.
[01:06 - 01:11]
Some people it's when they decide that they want to stop smoking it's relatively easy
[01:11 - 01:15]
and have little difficulty. But for others it's extremely
[01:15 - 01:20]
difficult. Smoking become an important part of their lives
[01:20 - 01:26]
and it's something when they do decide they want to stop smoking
[01:26 - 01:31]
becomes an important very important thing for them in a very difficult thing.
[01:31 - 01:35]
I imagine some people find it especially difficult in view of the fact that their
[01:35 - 01:39]
environments continue to remind them of the
[01:39 - 01:44]
pleasures that they had while smoking their friends who smoke. The television ads that were traced
[01:44 - 01:49]
smoking in such nice ways in drama such things as
[01:49 - 01:54]
having ashtrays all over the place all these things I would imagine support for the smokers are right
[01:54 - 01:59]
there are a lot of things that when a person is trying to stop smoking they're
[01:59 - 02:01]
reminded of smoking.
[02:01 - 02:08]
You mention ashtrays. This reminded me to take out a cigarette and smoke.
[02:08 - 02:14]
We go to a party everybody's lighting up and smoking.
[02:14 - 02:18]
Some people who have staff smoke talk about how difficult it is when they
[02:18 - 02:24]
particularly in the early phase of their stopping they speak of how difficult it is
[02:24 - 02:29]
being around people who smoke not so much that it irritates them but it smells so good.
[02:29 - 02:34]
I see you're involved in so called cessation clinic work that
[02:34 - 02:39]
is working with groups of people who voluntarily
[02:39 - 02:44]
sign up meet periodically in an effort to get some
[02:44 - 02:49]
help from others and stopping smoking. By that
[02:49 - 02:54]
does this mean that there is hope for stopping only among those who really want to
[02:54 - 02:56]
stop.
[02:56 - 03:00]
Basically I think this is so unless you
[03:00 - 03:05]
can motivate to people who don't care
[03:05 - 03:10]
about stopping. But the only way a person can stop is
[03:10 - 03:14]
be highly motivated by the people who come to the
[03:14 - 03:19]
groups at the cessation clinics have really thought quite a bit about this and it was an
[03:19 - 03:24]
impulsive move or impulsive move
[03:24 - 03:29]
that product into the clinic that they had to. Pay a high
[03:29 - 03:33]
price in terms of waiting to get into the clinic
[03:33 - 03:39]
and there is a small fee for
[03:39 - 03:43]
the clinic but this too is something that they had to think about
[03:43 - 03:46]
before joining it. So they're very motivated.
[03:46 - 03:50]
I've noticed a lot of smokers use various shall we say
[03:50 - 03:54]
rationalizations for why they smoke. Do they discuss these
[03:54 - 03:59]
rationalizations in smoking clinics. Do they you know mention I don't smoke that
[03:59 - 04:04]
much of the damage is already done so really why should I stop now. Or
[04:04 - 04:09]
you gotta die of something. Something. Are any of these many different reasons the people use
[04:09 - 04:12]
for for not stopping at these disguises.
[04:12 - 04:16]
Actually when someone gets to the clinic I think they've.
[04:16 - 04:22]
Decided pretty much that they don't need these rationalizations. However there are times
[04:22 - 04:27]
when the going gets rough that they may start rationalizing and denying
[04:27 - 04:31]
the need for stopping smoking.
[04:31 - 04:36]
And this is something that's a human problem is
[04:36 - 04:40]
that we don't like to face things that are.
[04:40 - 04:44]
Unpleasant and people when they're
[04:44 - 04:49]
faced with the reality of smoking will resort quite often
[04:49 - 04:54]
to denying that reality exists. I may say yeah I know it is. In
[04:54 - 04:59]
reason I don't think the reality of a health threat right. The reality of the health threat.
[04:59 - 05:03]
This is the main appeal that suggests to smokers that they should stop the
[05:03 - 05:04]
threat.
[05:04 - 05:09]
In your experience do you find this is a major appeal for stopping in the people who come
[05:09 - 05:16]
to the clinics this is been a I think the main appeal.
[05:16 - 05:20]
They are often their doctors have told them that they never
[05:20 - 05:26]
really confronted them that if they don't stop they're going to be in a great deal of trouble.
[05:26 - 05:30]
As far as their life expectancy goes they are quite a few people have severe
[05:30 - 05:35]
physical illnesses because of the smoking. But almost
[05:35 - 05:40]
equally as important is the feeling of
[05:40 - 05:47]
the feeling that the smoking is getting the best of them that I hear something that they can't
[05:47 - 05:48]
lick.
[05:48 - 05:52]
They feel bad that they are able to master their smoking
[05:52 - 05:54]
but don't want to be hooked anymore.
[05:54 - 05:59]
Very somehow to conquer this saying they will be in better control
[05:59 - 06:04]
of themselves which is an appeal to venture I very definitely appealed to be able to feel that you
[06:04 - 06:06]
can control yourself.
[06:06 - 06:11]
What other appeals do the mere use of those who
[06:11 - 06:12]
encourage want to stop.
[06:12 - 06:17]
Yeah well these appeals are something that I don't particularly bring out
[06:17 - 06:21]
I think these are things that people have brought out in the clinics in the groups themselves
[06:21 - 06:26]
because different people have different things that appeal to them some of them have been
[06:26 - 06:29]
economics a brownout.
[06:29 - 06:32]
How much money it's costing them.
[06:32 - 06:35]
And it runs into quite a bit of money
[06:35 - 06:42]
when they have stopped and they feel quite good about feeling quite
[06:42 - 06:43]
good.
[06:43 - 06:48]
This is one appeal and they really feel better they really feel better and they feel better about themselves
[06:48 - 06:48]
too.
[06:48 - 06:53]
That's right they think they have a an increased self-esteem and feeling that they were able
[06:53 - 06:58]
to master this difficult
[06:58 - 07:03]
problem and it is a difficult problem. It's not something you can say well if you want to stop just
[07:03 - 07:08]
stop. So when someone does master a difficult problem they feel pretty good about it.
[07:08 - 07:12]
Do they talk about the improvement you know smell taste of
[07:12 - 07:16]
being able to walk up stairs without being winded that sort of thing.
[07:16 - 07:20]
Very definitely there have been a number of people who've had chronic emphysema
[07:20 - 07:26]
and severe coughing waking up in the middle of the night coughing and.
[07:26 - 07:32]
Quite a few of them have stopped smoking. When they stop smoking and stop coughing
[07:32 - 07:37]
they're able to taste their food better able to smell things better
[07:37 - 07:39]
generally better feeling.
[07:39 - 07:44]
Do they ever discuss smoking as a moral issue as a symbol
[07:44 - 07:47]
of you know and he wife so anything like that.
[07:47 - 07:53]
No this is something that's never really been brought up and I groups.
[07:53 - 07:57]
What about techniques that would help smokers drop. Should
[07:57 - 08:03]
smokers cut down first or should they make a clean break and
[08:03 - 08:04]
just stop.
[08:04 - 08:08]
Well this too depends on the type of smoker.
[08:08 - 08:13]
I think first of all it's very important for the smoker to
[08:13 - 08:18]
be very conscious of his efforts to stop smoking and
[08:18 - 08:24]
tell himself he's going to stop smoking and then
[08:24 - 08:27]
try and get some understanding of why he is smoking.
[08:27 - 08:33]
And this is something that Lou is the feel of self-knowledge here
[08:33 - 08:38]
insight into the reasons why he smokes and how he uses cigarettes really does help him.
[08:38 - 08:43]
Yeah it does help because if he is a little better understanding he better able to control
[08:43 - 08:47]
something that if he didn't understand what was causing it.
[08:47 - 08:51]
So if he says I smoke because when I'm tense I need something to help me
[08:51 - 08:56]
relax. So next time he's tense and he really feels the need for a cigarette.
[08:56 - 09:01]
If you understand this process maybe you can get rid of his tension in some other way then strain.
[09:01 - 09:08]
What about the use of drugs to help people stop smoking.
[09:08 - 09:13]
So far in the groups we've had we haven't resorted to drugs you know I
[09:13 - 09:13]
imagine.
[09:13 - 09:20]
Though I don't I imagine that there will be
[09:20 - 09:25]
instances in maybe instances were of people maybe suffering from a great deal of tension
[09:25 - 09:29]
anxiety and in stopping smoking and
[09:29 - 09:35]
if the tranquilizers may be of benefit under supervision medical
[09:35 - 09:38]
supervision and I think this could be helpful.
[09:38 - 09:43]
But tranquilizers are not prescribed as a routine measure and in a sort of
[09:43 - 09:48]
know at these clinics we don't prescribe it if you ever feel that it would be necessary and I have
[09:48 - 09:52]
felt this was so. In our particular groups they'd be referred to their physician
[09:52 - 09:54]
for determination.
[09:54 - 09:59]
What about substitutes for smoking that many of the smokers are trying to stop. Reach for
[09:59 - 10:03]
candy and go and give a deep breathing exercises that are some times
[10:03 - 10:09]
recommended for stopping in the particularly in the early phases.
[10:09 - 10:14]
People will try different substitutes again the substances are best for them
[10:14 - 10:19]
some people will try to deep breathing some people do it. Eat
[10:19 - 10:23]
candy chew gum chewing a
[10:23 - 10:24]
pencil.
[10:24 - 10:28]
The more they've been hooked on gum candy and pencils instead of cigarettes.
[10:28 - 10:33]
Usually not usually in the beginning. They may find that they're doing this more
[10:33 - 10:36]
but then after a period of time they're no longer hooked.
[10:36 - 10:41]
So it's just a matter of learning this habit right over a long critic and this is something that
[10:41 - 10:43]
helps to unlearn.
[10:43 - 10:47]
What about trying to avoid smoking situations I suppose it could be
[10:47 - 10:52]
interpreted as running away from life but do any of the people try to
[10:52 - 10:55]
avoid situations in which they may be tempted.
[10:55 - 11:00]
Yeah I don't. I feel that sometimes the avoiding
[11:00 - 11:05]
situation is nothing to be ashamed of. Again this is
[11:05 - 11:10]
particularly in the early phases where you need everything you can get your hands on to help you
[11:10 - 11:14]
with the smoking situations is something that will make of it
[11:14 - 11:20]
facilitate their smoking then I think that they should avoid a smoking situation
[11:20 - 11:25]
and time this doesn't mean that forever they can never enter a smoke filled room.
[11:25 - 11:30]
Now a person who's trying to stop is trying to take something out of his life
[11:30 - 11:34]
that perhaps has formerly been fairly important to him. Does he need
[11:34 - 11:39]
to turn to other things. Does he need to develop new forms of enjoyment
[11:39 - 11:44]
new routines to substitute for this or can he make a fairly
[11:44 - 11:48]
clean break without a big change in his lifestyle as it were.
[11:48 - 11:54]
Sometimes people have to make some changes in
[11:54 - 11:59]
your daily habits. You write in order to give
[11:59 - 12:04]
up something that's been so important that person wants to have something
[12:04 - 12:10]
one wants to get something from it. And this is one of the fears
[12:10 - 12:15]
and that people have one is dumping smoking but something's being cut out of their
[12:15 - 12:16]
lives right.
[12:16 - 12:21]
Now what about help from others. Those of us who are around persons who are trying to stop
[12:21 - 12:27]
what could we do to help him. What about kind of company really reminding them or
[12:27 - 12:29]
criticizing when their smoking was healthy.
[12:29 - 12:34]
Well this is certainly something that people family and
[12:34 - 12:39]
friends feel that's going to be helpful but is usually something that's going to bug you.
[12:39 - 12:43]
And sometimes smokers when they're bugs will smoke.
[12:43 - 12:48]
And this is a great way of telling someone to get off my
[12:48 - 12:51]
back and start smoking.
[12:51 - 12:54]
What about the use of praise or encouragement.
[12:54 - 12:58]
This should be used delicately. And not too
[12:58 - 13:03]
often. Sometimes you can make people feel like they're doing
[13:03 - 13:06]
it for other people and not for themselves people.
[13:06 - 13:11]
Most successfully when they do it for themselves so it is helpful to get some cred
[13:11 - 13:16]
praising her judgement and and to expend some
[13:16 - 13:21]
concern periodically and perhaps one of the better techniques would be to join.
[13:21 - 13:26]
If you're a smoker to join the person who's trying to stop in his efforts to stop his then in other words
[13:26 - 13:27]
stop yourself.
[13:27 - 13:32]
Yeah I have. When people have other people around them there are attempting to stop
[13:32 - 13:35]
smoking this is very helpful very supportive.
[13:35 - 13:40]
I suppose smokers who are trying to stop do need all the help they can get. Thank you Dr
[13:40 - 13:45]
Baron for meeting with us today. It will be quite interesting I think to observe the changes
[13:45 - 13:50]
in smoking behavior over the next several years. Smokers are more likely to
[13:50 - 13:55]
enjoy less and less social support for smoking and they will undoubtedly
[13:55 - 14:00]
be more and more successful in quitting. There is little doubt in my mind
[14:00 - 14:04]
that cigarette smoking as we have known it is on the way out.
[14:04 - 14:09]
You have been listening to the smoking dilemma a series which offers provocative Dialogue
[14:09 - 14:14]
Concerning the smoking problem in this country. Today's discussion dealt with the topic how
[14:14 - 14:19]
to quit smoking. Your program host was Dr. Ralph grounder professor of health education at
[14:19 - 14:24]
San Diego State College. His guest was Dr. Irving Baron psychiatrist and
[14:24 - 14:29]
consultant to smoking cessation clinics. This program was produced by Katy B
[14:29 - 14:33]
S FM at the Radio Television Center at center Jago State College. This is the
[14:33 - 14:35]
national educational radio network.
🔍